Two neighbors argue about the tree between their houses. One wants it cut down. The other wants it saved.

The easy version gives the tree lover a childhood memory and the tree cutter an ugly temper. By the second paragraph, the reader knows whom to applaud. The argument may continue for pages, but the story has already made its decision.

Try giving the neighbor who wants the tree removed a reason that is difficult to dismiss.

Make both positions cost something

The tree's roots have cracked the shared drain. Every heavy rain sends water into the downstairs flat, where a tenant has already lost furniture. Repairing the pipe without removing the tree is possible, but expensive. The neighbor who wants to save it cannot afford the full bill.

Now the person defending the tree is not merely protecting beauty. They are asking someone else to carry a risk. And the person seeking removal is not merely impatient with nature. They may be protecting a home.

Neither character needs to be secretly cruel. They can disagree because they are responsible for different things.

Don't confuse fairness with equal correctness

Giving an opposing character a fair hearing does not mean every position deserves the same outcome. A character may be misinformed, selfish, or plainly wrong. The craft question is whether the story has shown what makes that position persuasive to the person holding it.

One useful test: can you write the strongest version of the argument you least want to win, without adding a wink to tell the reader it is foolish?

Another: if you switched the point-of-view character, would the scene still contain a real problem? If the answer is no, you may have built a speech with costumes rather than a conflict.

Let the decision leave a mark

Suppose the neighbors agree to save the tree and share the repair costs. That is not a tidy victory if the tenant must wait another wet season. Suppose they cut it down. That is not a tidy victory if the street loses its only shade.

The story becomes more interesting when the choice solves one problem and makes another visible. Readers need not agree with the decision to understand why someone made it.

When a scene feels too easy, ask not which character needs a better speech, but which consequence the story has been protecting them from.

Part of Beyond the Known, an independent journal by Arin Vale.

Related craft: The Villain Who Gets the Facts Right — when an antagonist's evidence is genuinely strong

Read our editorial approach